Home » Folklore » Testing Grandma’s Knowledge – Home Remedies Under Scientific Eye

Testing Grandma’s Knowledge – Home Remedies Under Scientific Eye

by Jennifer B Graham in Folklore, October 28, 2007

We have all heard the old wives tales about what works best for common ailments. It turns out that some of those treatments have now gotten some scientific proof to back them up, while others seem to be a myth. Wanna find out which home remedies Grandma was right about the whole time?

One of my warmest childhood memories is when my grandmother propped me up in bed with a steaming bowl of chicken noodle soup whenever I had a stinking cold. Miraculously, I’d be up on my feet, and as right as rain in no time. How did granny get to be such a medical genius? She, no doubt, learnt it from her mother, who learnt it from her mother, who learnt it from her mother… and there you have the origin of Old Wives Tales (OWT) and the reason they are still with us today.

While granny was on the mark with some cures, others were somewhat suspect. Let’s look at the truth and fallacies of some OWT.

Chicken Noodle Soup is the Best Remedy for the Common Cold – TRUE!

Granny was spot on with her cure. Researchers offer that steaming soup clears nasal congestion and provides the body with necessary hydration to flush out viral bugs. According to an ABC News report, Dr. Stephen Rennard, a pulmonary expert at the University of Nebraska Medical Center, found evidence that the soup contains anti-inflammatory properties that may help prevent a cold’s wretched side effects.

A University of California study has shown amino acid cysteine to be a common by-product of chicken soup. This amino acid has the same components as acetylecysteine, an antibiotic prescribed to people with respiratory infections.

Don’t Go Out With Wet Hair, You’ll Catch a Cold – FALSE!

Many are the times I’ve ascribed a cold to a particular event such as my head getting wet and cold thereby lowering my resistance to cold germs. But what about those times I got wet from walking in the rain, and did not catch a cold.

Scientists tell us that colds are caused by over 200 different strains of viruses known as rhinoviruses. (It should be noted that colds are not caused by the same viruses responsible for influenza.) The Common Cold Unit in Salisbury, England, conducted repeated experiments in which people were left shivering in the cold and did not come down with any more colds than those who stayed warm. Finger to nose contact is the most likely means of viral transmission. Viruses are passed on from person to person through spray from coughing or sneezing. Physicians say the best way to avoid colds is to keep hands clean and keep them away from noses.

For an Upset Tummy Drink Flat Coke and Eat Crackers – TRUE!

Tell someone you have the trots or skitters and it seems to induce mirth. Diarrhea is no matter for merriment, especially for the sufferer. Health Care expert Anna Mickell tells us this most commonly caused by a virus or bacterium that has made its way into food or water. Other causes may include rich food, too much alcohol, emotional upheaval, reaction to drugs and food allergies.

Preventing dehydration is the main treatment in the initial stages of diarrhea. Mickell recommends small amounts of clear, lightly sweetened fluid every hour. Ideal fluids include flat coke, diluted lemonade and weak cordial. When the diarrhea has subsided, the patient should eat bland, non-greasy foods such as dry bread, crackers, clear soups and poached eggs.

For a Sore Throat Gargle With Warm Salt Water – TRUE!

Complain to my husband about a sore throat and you can take it to the bank that he’s going to say, “Go gargle with salt water.” The experts agree with him. (I married a genius!) Researchers at the University of Maryland state that most of sore throat cases are caused by viruses on which antibiotics would be wasted. Granny’s tried and tested remedy of a good gargle with salt water (½ teaspoon salt in 240mls warm water) every three to four hours, is not only the safest and least expensive, but probably the most effective treatment.

Feed a Cold and Starve a Fever – MAYBE?

When you feel like death warmed over and are delirious with fever, the last thing on your mind is food. Cold and flu experts at
MyPharmacy
suggest that rather than fasting or feasting, the wisest course of action when you are ill is to eat when you are hungry. However, it is important that you eat nutritious food and supplements to help regain your strength. Drinking fluids is highly recommended. Broths not only provide fluid, but also protein and nutrients necessary for healing. Of course you can always count on Grandma’s old standby – chicken noodle soup.

For Nosebleeds Put a Wad of Paper Under Your Lip, Put Ice on the Back of Your Neck or Tip Your Head Back – FALSE!

Whatever was Gran thinking when she came up with the wad of paper under the lip? Go figure that one out? Experts tell us that because the nose has many blood vessels and is situated in a prominent position on the face, trauma to the face can cause nosebleeds. Nosebleeds can also occur when the nasal membranes dry out and crack. This problem is often encountered in dry climates or during winter months when indoor heaters dry out the air. Some anti-inflammatory medications may also cause nosebleeds.

Health care experts advise that the best way to stop a nosebleed is to squeeze or pinch the nostrils together with the thumb and index finger. Hold this position for about 5 minutes. Repeat the technique until the bleeding stops. Sit, relax and keep the head elevated. Do not lie down or put your head between your legs. Apply crushed ice to the nose and cheek areas. After a nosebleed, rest with your head elevated.

The Best Cure for a “Hangover Breakfast” – Black Coffee, Two Eggs, Tomato Juice and an Aspirin – All Mixed Together – FALSE!

Like most people, I do not like to suffer. And the best way to avoid it is not to eat or drink in excess. But people, being people, will always have gluttons for punishment. Consider some facts about the effects of alcohol on the body:

Medical experts state that the body absorbs about 90 percent of the alcohol in a drink. The rest is excreted through the breath, perspiration and urine. On average, a normal liver can process 10 grams of alcohol per hour – the equivalent of one glass of wine, half a pint of beer, or one shot of 80 proof spirits.

Alcohol is a depressant that slows down the activity of the central nervous system by replacing the water around the nervous cells in the body.

There are, however, a few things you can do to make a hangover less severe. Before drinking eat a substantial meal or have at least one glass of milk to protect your stomach lining. After drinking, have a pint of water before bedtime to minimize dehydration.

The bad news, according to experts, is that a hangover can’t be cured once you have one. Some cures may exacerbate the problem. Aspirin and ibuprofen can irritate the stomach lining. Acetaminophen can strain the liver. Copious amounts of coffee can give you a caffeine buzz. Sleep would be a better remedy. Better to drink a lot of fruit juice or eat something sweet and wait for the sugar to absorb the alcohol.

Rub Butter on a Burn – FALSE!

Drs. Rutherford and Dowshen of
KidsHealth.org
say never apply butter, grease, powder or any remedies to a first-degree burn. Before you phone for medical assistance, run cool water over the burned area or hold a clean, cold compress on the burn until the pain subsides. Remove clothing (that is not stuck to the flesh) from the burned area. If water is not available use any cold drinkable fluid, but do not use ice. If the burn area is small, loosely cover it with a sterile gauze pad or bandage. For second and third degree burns follow the instructions for first degree burns. Do not break blisters.

Cure Hiccups by Swallowing Sugar, Sucking on a Lemon, Drinking from a Far Side of a Glass – TRUE!

The medical term for hiccups (hiccoughs), according to Dr. Garry Wilkes, is known as singultus, originating from Latin, which means “the act of one catching one’s breath while sobbing.” Hiccups appear to serve no purpose in humans or other mammals. A hiccup bout is any episode that lasts for more than a few minutes. The reason many traditional remedies are effective is because they employ methods that stimulate components of the hiccup reflex.

And Finally, Laughter is Good for the Soul – TRUE

Grandma didn’t say this but researchers at the University of Maryland who have studied the influence of laughter on the body, concluded that a good guffaw has a positive effect on blood flow, the immune response and blood sugar levels. Check out the net for some more outrageous OWT and if for some reason you develop hiccups between your chuckles, you’ll know what to do.

35
Liked it

User Comments

  1. Puzzled

    On October 28, 2007 at 3:55 pm


    How can drinking from the far side of a glass solve hiccups???

  2. cool runnin'

    On October 28, 2007 at 6:41 pm


    The concentration that you exert trying to drink from the far side of the glass must make you forget about your hiccups altogether.
    Heck how do I know, go ask your Granny!

  3. John

    On October 29, 2007 at 5:21 am


    Excellent Work!!!

  4. Judith

    On October 29, 2007 at 8:25 am


    Good to know that some OWT don’t even come from Granny — that is a wise, wise man you married! I look forward to the next installment.

  5. Compadre

    On October 29, 2007 at 12:22 pm


    Good WISDOM here..I bet your Mate never stays sick for long!

  6. Marion

    On October 29, 2007 at 3:09 pm


    What a WOW (woman of wisdom) you are. I concur with your grandmother’s great wisdom as it echoes my mother’s remedies in my own childhood. Keep the wisdom coming!

  7. Judy Sheldon

    On October 31, 2007 at 5:51 pm


    Thank you for the tips.

  8. valli

    On November 1, 2007 at 3:20 am


    Thank you very much for the information.

  9. Dee Huff

    On November 1, 2007 at 5:57 pm


    Thanks for a very entertaining and informative article. I’ve always used a heaped teaspoon of sugar as an instant hiccup cure and it invariably works!

  10. Evelyn

    On November 2, 2007 at 10:38 am


    Warm water and salt work every time for my sore throat – good to know it’s not just “the placebo effect.” Interesting article!

  11. Charly

    On November 3, 2007 at 6:27 am


    Acetylecysteine is not an antibiotic. It’s a mucolytic, an agent that acts dissolving mucus.

  12. Michael Pan

    On November 4, 2007 at 9:45 am


    Well, that was wierd. But slighty interesting

  13. Liane Schmidt

    On November 7, 2007 at 2:54 pm


    Interesting, well written and well laid out article.

    Best wishes.

    Sincerely,

    -Liane Schmidt.

  14. Bev Petracek

    On November 8, 2007 at 4:58 pm


    Well written and interesting. Confirms some of the treatments that I have found beneficial over the years. Ever heard of rubbing Vicks Vaporub on your feet for a cold…works well.

  15. Jamie White

    On November 13, 2007 at 5:54 am


    A teaspoonful of vinegar works instantly for curing hiccups. I’ve never known it to fail. Just close your eyes and imagine you’re eating french fries!

  16. Ruby Hawk

    On November 22, 2007 at 7:04 pm


    I always use salt water for a sore throat and it does work every time. I gave it to my children too, but they hated it.

    I always put ice on their necks when they had a nose bleed and pressed the upper part of the nose, not the lower part of the nose. that always worked.

  17. Colette

    On December 5, 2007 at 1:38 am


    I really like this. Would be great if you could compile a complete A to Z of all the old wives tails that work – I always believed there was something in them!! Well done.

  18. quiet voice

    On December 28, 2007 at 12:04 am


    Hi, I found this very, very interesting. You certainly put a lot of effort into the article and it is appreciated. Take care.

Post Comment

Powered by Powered by Triond