Comments on: Unsolved Mysteries Part 1: Cabin 28

By: meankitty

meankitty — Tue, 10 Apr 2012 21:48:36 +0000

There is a lot of information coming out about the case at http://www.keddiemurdersfilm.com/forum.

By: Inyurface

Inyurface — Wed, 22 Feb 2012 21:33:51 +0000

You People r so dumb \” the strangers\” was based off a murder that happened in february, february 11 2005, The victims were kristen mckay and james hoyst. But the movie did say inspired by true events, so i did some searching from sites more reliable then wikipedia. And i found that the movie was based in fqct off of 3 murder cases. The setting of the kill came from the kennie story. The victoms first names were kristen and james but the familys changed their last names so as to not attract to much attention toward them. The real last names are not revealed \”obviously\” and the third is outdoor scenery taken from the tate murders aka charlie manson.

By: xoLey27ox

xoLey27ox — Tue, 19 Jul 2011 20:54:03 +0000

Im not a Pro or a Psychic at Findinq out thinqs about Anythinq that Nobody knows . I have Read many many MANY stories on both Cases The Strangers && Cabin 28 . All of the stories i havr read had said that The Strangers were based on Cabin 28 . I have read all the Comments on this Paqe , im not qoinq to continue this Horror movies are great && all this Crap people are repeatinq . I have REASON to believe that The Strangers is NOT based on Cabin 28 !
For O1 – The cabin 28 murders did NOT look like they were tortured before they killed them . It infact looked as if they went in && Delibretly killed them when they first got in . While The strangers were tortured && terrorised before the Masked killers even touched them .
O2 – in the strangers they had a friend killed so did cabin 28 BUT … ANY WERE YOU READ THEY SAY THEY PUT THAT IN TO MAKE THE MOVIE LONGER !
I have alot more Reasons to believe they are both DIFFERENT cases && if you dont believe me with this then dont , but all the cases i have read without the endinq , before i read the ending i have been right as what had happend .

P.s i believe the Cabin 28 Killer(s) was a Friend that might have come over bcause if nobody heard screaminq then they must have not been scared of the killers ! I beliece they gave some type of drug in a drink or food the people ate / drank that made them pass out && durinq that they killed those people , the Kids i still dont know Why they left them there to witness that . But this is how i feel && what i think Happened !

By: sean

sean — Mon, 25 Apr 2011 00:52:15 +0000

cant understand y people take such interest in these forums ,,have u not discovered girlfriends,or pubs nightclubs,ecstasy,cocaine,get ou a bit more

By: jackie

jackie — Sun, 17 Oct 2010 22:33:12 +0000

the movie is great the ending leaves one empty it is just a scary movie folks not a lot of answers, other made to order scare us to death they at least have better ending. never seen a movie so scary and end just nothing what a bummer

By: Zephyr

Zephyr — Fri, 17 Sep 2010 16:33:17 +0000

The single-most worthless forum I’ve ever read.

By: Alan

Alan — Thu, 01 Jul 2010 21:41:51 +0000

It might have been Devil worshipers, the young girl could have been a virgin which they sacrificed.

By: Joe

Joe — Sat, 26 Jun 2010 06:01:41 +0000

Sorry for the mispellings but I hope you get the points of my argument. Prayers to the family of this tragedy.

By: Joe

Joe — Sat, 26 Jun 2010 05:56:39 +0000

I agree with many of Matt.r’s comments. As Matt says Sociopaths live among us as seemingly normal folks. The biggest mystery of the cabin 28 murders is why leave anyone alive and why take Tina Sharp away from the cabin. Yes the identity of the killer or killers is a mystery we all would love solved but we already know what kind of person or persons the killer or killers were. They were Sociopaths who have no remorse or guilt. The killer or killers are brutal, un-repentant, and totally evil. Which makes the fact that anyone was left alive even more of a mystery. In addition 3 of the four victims were under age 18 which means this killer had nor problem killing children. So why were the toddlers in back left alive? I just don’t know. It makes no sense. Perhaps the killers did not know they were there. Perhaps the killer or killers simply wanted to hurry and kill the ones who could Identify them, Take Tina Sharp, and do who knows what, and leave. Maybe the killers intended to come back and finish the kids off but after they were done they decided it was to risky to go back and the kids were no threat to identify them. No one knows the real answers. But again the true mystery in the cabin 28 murders is not so much of who the killer or killer was but has to do with the fact that anyone was left alive and why take Tina Sharp out of the cabin at all. I agree with Matt. Tina Sharp is what the sick killer or killers were after. Just like Joseph Edward Duncan killed the family in Idaho to molest those children the killer of those in Cabin 28 were after the same thing in Tina Sharp. In closing I must express I mean no disrespect to any of the surviving family in my speculation as to what might have happened. If anyone reads this please know this. Those beutiful people who suffered at the hands of evil that deserve our respect. But those in Plumas county need to know that the killer or killers were no boogie man. They are or were real people. Your town is not haunted. Perhaps the killer or killers lived among you or in a nearby community or perhaps the killer or killers were strangers but regardless they are real and can be indentified and brought to justice if they are still alive. I hope the cabin 28 murders teach us all a valuable lesson. When some invades your home while your still in it then your in mortal danger. Don’t go out quietly. Don’t allow yourselfs to be tied up. Fight like you never fought before. If it is my time to go I am going out kicking, screaming, biting, clubing, knifing, shooting, or what ever else it takes to inflict as much pain on those trying to harm me as I can. Don’t believe the lies of the killers. Once your tied up your done for. My prayers to the surviving family members and my hope is some day you have your answers.

Sincerely,

Joe.

By: Matt.r

Matt.r — Fri, 25 Jun 2010 11:34:23 +0000

Last Comment on this case. The true mystery of this crime is not the murders really. Sociopaths, and that is what murderer or murderers are, are beyond reason. Sociopaths kill without remorse, have no conscience, and live among us seemingly normal people. There not like Psychopaths who display outward clues that they are unstable. Sociopaths know killing is wrong but they feel they are above the rules and have absolutely no remorse. I don’t feel this was a drug revenge crime as some claim. People tend to point to any unexplained crime as a drug crime. No the biggest mystery of the Cabin 28 murders is why they took Tina Sharp and did Tina Sharp die the same night just up at the falls or did she live a bit longer. Or did the killer drive around with Tina Sharps deceased body for years and decide to drop it off. I believe Tina Sharp died that night up at the falls. The killer or killers purpose in my opinion was to assault Tina in some way, the purpose of the whole crime, and then kill her when they were done. Then the killer or killers cleaned up at the falls. Some how the police just did not find her body. If you claim otherwise that presents scary posibilities and it means the killer was more likely not a stranger but a local. If Tina lived a short time that means she was probally kept in a local community and likewise if her body was kept the killer lived close enough to just dump part of the body out one day as he was driving by the falls. So the mystery is why take Tina away from the cabin and did Tina die that same night or some time later and all the mystery one wants to imagine that that could involve. Again the Police never forget and if they can solve this they will. God Bless The Victims Of Violent Crime.