You are here: Home » Philosophy » Nietzsche, Hitler and the Superman

Nietzsche, Hitler and the Superman

A comparison of the ideas of both Hitler and Nietzsche to see how close these were. To compare the “overman” of Nietzsche to see how close th claims of some of Hitler’s supporters were that Hitler was this super being.

Both men were anti-democratic. They believed in the rule of “the best”. Nietzsche is vitriolic about those he calls “the rabble”. The rabble, he says, only contaminate everything and to deal with them is a betrayal by the rulers. He goes on to say. “And on the rulers turned I my back, when I saw what they now call ruling, to traffic and bargain for power with the rabble.” (Thus Spake Zarathustra, p.149. See also p.255.)

Hitler and Nietzsche, then, were themselves remarkably similar. It might be possible for someone with the expertise to go into the psychopathology of these two strange and terrifying persons. They glorified war, they were elitist and the despised the common people and democracy. They both had some measure of musical and artistic talent and believed in a similar aristocratic social system and in a subservient position for women. Both men had serious personality flaws and both compensated for these with aggressive, even deranged behaviour. Both of them fiercely believed in their own wisdom and rectitude and so were authoritarians of the worst sort.

Indeed it could be argued that Hitler in his career and his personality is the most damning condemnation of the ideas promulgated by Nietzsche that it is possible to find. That both men were born into the same race and nation may say something about the social psychology of that nation or it may be coincidence, I do not think so.

1
Liked it
User Comments
  1. hansimann

    On February 20, 2010 at 7:55 am


    Roger, first, the National Socialist salute is not ‘Zieg Heil’, but ‘Sieg Heil’. Second, I would recommend a book you might not be aware of but one which does a great job of placing Nietzsche into his historic context: The Nietzsche Legacy in Germany, 1890-1990.

    The book will show you the origins of the counter-culture of today in Nietzsche as much else that is dynamic and revolutionary. To equate N. with Hitler so easily is kind of a gross simplification, to say the least.

Post Comment
Powered by Powered by Triond