You are here: Home » Psychology » Was Sigmund Freud Right or Wrong with His Psycho-analysis and Sex Motivation Theories

Was Sigmund Freud Right or Wrong with His Psycho-analysis and Sex Motivation Theories

Sigmund Freud invented and developed psycho-analysis. He also said that sex was the basic human motivation. But was he right? Here is my analysis and opinion. Freud invented the subconscious mind, the Id, memory repression, the libido, and much more. Non-directive counselling evolved from Freud. Others disagree with him though. Sex or food?

Image via Wikipedia

Sigmund Freud was an Austrian Neurologist who lived from 1856-1939. Some rate him as highly as Darwin and the like. Freud famously established the psychiatric practice of psycho-analysis: “talk therapy”. He indirectly created “non –directive counselling” (Carl Rogers et al) and did great work on interpreting dreams.  Freud gave us words such as “unconscious mind”, “Id”, “ego”, “super- ego” and “repressed memory”. He was very influential with his whole philosophy. Many dub him the “Father of Psychology”. Freud also came up with the sensational theory that sex drive is “the primary motivational force in humans”.

Only trouble is, Freud was wrong: his psycho-analysis can do more harm than good and his sex theory is flawed

Most of Freud’s theories are great. Yet many scientists and practitioners find some fault with them.  Hans Eysenck (the I.Q. man no less) said that Freud, “Set psychiatry back one hundred years.” Peter Medawar declared that Psycho-Analysis was the, “most stupendous intellectual confidence trick of the twentieth century.”

It was mentioned in my Careers work article that the “Cognitive Behavioural” school of counselling sees the non-directive model as too wishy-washy. However, instinct tells me that dragging up those horrible repressed memories (during psycho-analysis) cannot always be good for the patient. A few years back I saw a television programme telling of how some Jews had bad memories repressed during and after The Holocaust. Generally those who kept their memories hidden and “got on with it” did much better than those who were “counselled” (and their memories dredged back up)! It was found that the human brain actively protects itself by burying traumatic memories deep in the subconscious. This buys time for the individual concerned to come to terms with it all, over the years, or just “forget”. “Bottling things up” can sometimes be for the best.

Sex is Not the prime motivator, but libido is

Actually another new word from Freud was “Libedo”, or “Life Drive”. It would seem that he recognised that a human’s first priority is to Survive. It is instinctive for us to seek water, food and shelter. After that, we will seek sex in order to procreate, so that our genes will survive.

Somehow it was the “sex” thing that sensationally got publicised. Again instinct tells me that nourishment must come first. This probably explains why we have such an obesity problem today. Food, shelter, then finally sex. Maybe Freud was trying to get the equivalent of Google rankings – publicity – in putting forward sex as the key. Readers may differ with me on this though. In my humble opinion, Freud was indeed wrong.

To see how Freud indirectly influenced my Careers Guidance work go to:

http://socyberty.com/society/careers-work-advice-help-counselling-guidance-and-information/

-you will see towards the end how my counselling was indeed a type of psychotherapy!

Paul Butters

4
Liked it
User Comments
  1. Sheila Barnhill

    On April 1, 2011 at 1:20 pm


    Wow, you’re good!

  2. PaulB

    On April 1, 2011 at 2:57 pm


    As the actress said to the bishop. LOL. Thanks Sheila.

  3. Thespeakman

    On April 1, 2011 at 3:26 pm


    That was a fantastic article – very well researched. Thank you for sharing that… Now tell me about your mother

  4. Martin Kloess

    On April 1, 2011 at 10:13 pm


    well done. thank you.

  5. Butterfly Musings

    On April 2, 2011 at 7:28 pm


    I have to go to the store, but come back and read all of this, sounds very interesting:}

  6. PaulB

    On April 3, 2011 at 6:34 pm


    Everyone sitting comfortably?

  7. razor7

    On April 6, 2011 at 4:18 pm


    good information..
    thanks for sharring..
    http://scienceray.com/biology/ecology/about-elephant-life/

  8. Andy Laa

    On April 14, 2011 at 12:46 pm


    Good ole Freud.

    He had a foot fetish and unusual feelings towards his mother I do believe :P

  9. lightfang

    On May 16, 2011 at 11:54 am


    Nice share and nice info, keep writing and earn with triond.

    For everyone please see my article and give comment on this, don\’t missed to put your articles link on comment box, I will see and comment too on your articles soon, and hope we can do this everytime.
    Healt Benefits of Raspberry
    Real Health Benefits of Strawberry

  10. itsmejohn

    On May 27, 2011 at 11:14 pm


    A good read, very informative. Keep rolling…!

    John

    http://www.myblogtimes.com

  11. GoldenAsh

    On June 11, 2011 at 5:48 pm


    Freud is considered the “Father of Psychology” by many people. Nice post.

  12. PaulB

    On June 12, 2011 at 2:13 pm


    Freud is indeed the father of my beloved **talking therapies**. Everything has its light and dark side….

  13. PaulB

    On June 20, 2011 at 7:03 am


    Today I have tweaked this article a bit, acknowledging Freud as the Father of Psychology. Hope you enjoyed.

  14. PaulB

    On November 9, 2011 at 12:08 pm


    Thanks to those who keep on viewing this article. Something here seems to interest people. Like to tell me about your childhood?

Post Comment
Powered by Powered by Triond
-->